Went to Bethany early in my pregnancy. Made it VERY clear, multiple times (before I even walked in the door, in fact) that I was not sure what I wanted to do--parenting or adoption--and that I needed help and information on both options. They promised to walk me through both options and help me no matter which I chose.
When I had attended several appointments and finally asked for help in putting together a parenting plan, finding community resources to help me parent, and so on, they refused.
They have refused to provide the life-long post-placement counseling they promised.
When I returned to them post-relinquishment and asked for information on support groups, books to help a post-relinquishment mother, etc., they could not provide me with a single resource... I ended up telling THEM about the closest CUB meeting. (And later found out they don't support CUB, anyway, because it's too radical... which is absurd--Google CUB.)
Bethany has individual people who do a good job, but the organization as a whole is corrupt, in my opinion. It is a huge supporter of the NCFA, which lobbies for closed records, closed adoptions, and which put out the booklet "Birth Mother, Good Mother" as a way to market infant adoption--to make women feel that in order to be good mothers, they need to relinquish their children.
Bethany's pamphlets and website alone should be enough to make people RUN in the other direction--there are lies and half-truths and pro-relinquishment spin all over the place. (Check out the "Options" pages on the Unplanned Pregnancy section of the website. Notice how under "Parenting," the NEGATIVES are listed first... and under "Adoption," the POSITIVES are listed first.) There is no mention that open adoptions aren't legally enforceable, either--website makes it sound like it's all up to the natural mom how much contact she has. And no mention of increased risk of depression, PTSD, substance abuse, etc etc after relinquishing a child. Basically... everything is whitewashed.
I could go on and on and on about individual horror stories, about the brainwashing and subtly coercive methods, but I'll stop and just say this:
No mother should relinquish her child through this agency--period. And no adoptive parent should adopt through this agency--period. Unless you are comfortable with a portion of your fees going to SUPPORT denying adoptees their original birth certificates and their own records--then do NOT use this agency, even if you have found an individual office that isn't too bad.
Hi,
I'm a reporter with ABC News and I'm interested in investigating Bethany adoption services. Would you be willing to talk to me over the phone about your experience sometime Tuesday or Wednesday of this week? For now I'm just feeling out the topic so you can stay anonymous if you prefer. Feel free to google my name and ABC to confirm that I am, in fact, a reporter :)
Let me know if you are interested, thanks for your time!
It's unfortunate your experience was negative because our local Bethany agency was wonderful. They stressed over and over that open adoptions are most of what they handle, and in our state there's a law enforcing any legal contract regarding visitation between birth parents and adoptees. It's all a matter of what is agreed upon prior to placement.
While I understand your desire to parent your baby, the question to be answered is what is best for the baby? In a perfect society, there would be all kinds of free programs to help you through your difficult time, and your baby would have everything it needs, including your time at home with him or her. But the reality of life is that it's expensive to have a baby, and that the daily pressures of life don't ease up simply because now you are a single mom... they only get tougher. The second sad reality is that it's much easier to place an infant for adoption than an older child. Older children placed for adoption, after you learn too late that you weren't ready to be a parent, spend a looooong time in foster care.
Maybe your Bethany agent was a little more experienced than you in the harshness of reality and was trying to save your little one from a life of struggle and disappointment.
Yes, Bethany has always been on the wrong side of reform. The NCFA lobbies in the best interest of agencies--not adoptees, not children, not First Parents, heck not really even in the best interest of Adoptive Parents. You can see from my adoption story (which I just posted with my rating) how sealed OBCs and lack of access to truthful information gave Bethany unimaginable power to manipulate both sets of my parents. When there is no truth and openness there are no checks and balances.
I understand what you are going through. Dealing with B.C.S. Was the worst thing that has ever happened to me, nothing about my adoption was legal. I have been trying to do my own investigation. If you would like to talk. E-mail me at:bramlett_anna@yahoo.com
Reviews
Serious ethical problems
Went to Bethany early in my pregnancy. Made it VERY clear, multiple times (before I even walked in the door, in fact) that I was not sure what I wanted to do--parenting or adoption--and that I needed help and information on both options. They promised to walk me through both options and help me no matter which I chose.
When I had attended several appointments and finally asked for help in putting together a parenting plan, finding community resources to help me parent, and so on, they refused.
They have refused to provide the life-long post-placement counseling they promised.
When I returned to them post-relinquishment and asked for information on support groups, books to help a post-relinquishment mother, etc., they could not provide me with a single resource... I ended up telling THEM about the closest CUB meeting. (And later found out they don't support CUB, anyway, because it's too radical... which is absurd--Google CUB.)
Bethany has individual people who do a good job, but the organization as a whole is corrupt, in my opinion. It is a huge supporter of the NCFA, which lobbies for closed records, closed adoptions, and which put out the booklet "Birth Mother, Good Mother" as a way to market infant adoption--to make women feel that in order to be good mothers, they need to relinquish their children.
Bethany's pamphlets and website alone should be enough to make people RUN in the other direction--there are lies and half-truths and pro-relinquishment spin all over the place. (Check out the "Options" pages on the Unplanned Pregnancy section of the website. Notice how under "Parenting," the NEGATIVES are listed first... and under "Adoption," the POSITIVES are listed first.) There is no mention that open adoptions aren't legally enforceable, either--website makes it sound like it's all up to the natural mom how much contact she has. And no mention of increased risk of depression, PTSD, substance abuse, etc etc after relinquishing a child. Basically... everything is whitewashed.
I could go on and on and on about individual horror stories, about the brainwashing and subtly coercive methods, but I'll stop and just say this:
No mother should relinquish her child through this agency--period. And no adoptive parent should adopt through this agency--period. Unless you are comfortable with a portion of your fees going to SUPPORT denying adoptees their original birth certificates and their own records--then do NOT use this agency, even if you have found an individual office that isn't too bad.
Interested in Investigating Bethany
Hi,
I'm a reporter with ABC News and I'm interested in investigating Bethany adoption services. Would you be willing to talk to me over the phone about your experience sometime Tuesday or Wednesday of this week? For now I'm just feeling out the topic so you can stay anonymous if you prefer. Feel free to google my name and ABC to confirm that I am, in fact, a reporter :)
Let me know if you are interested, thanks for your time!
Courtney Hutchison, ABC News
Not the same in every state.
It's unfortunate your experience was negative because our local Bethany agency was wonderful. They stressed over and over that open adoptions are most of what they handle, and in our state there's a law enforcing any legal contract regarding visitation between birth parents and adoptees. It's all a matter of what is agreed upon prior to placement.
While I understand your desire to parent your baby, the question to be answered is what is best for the baby? In a perfect society, there would be all kinds of free programs to help you through your difficult time, and your baby would have everything it needs, including your time at home with him or her. But the reality of life is that it's expensive to have a baby, and that the daily pressures of life don't ease up simply because now you are a single mom... they only get tougher. The second sad reality is that it's much easier to place an infant for adoption than an older child. Older children placed for adoption, after you learn too late that you weren't ready to be a parent, spend a looooong time in foster care.
Maybe your Bethany agent was a little more experienced than you in the harshness of reality and was trying to save your little one from a life of struggle and disappointment.
Ditto
Yes, Bethany has always been on the wrong side of reform. The NCFA lobbies in the best interest of agencies--not adoptees, not children, not First Parents, heck not really even in the best interest of Adoptive Parents. You can see from my adoption story (which I just posted with my rating) how sealed OBCs and lack of access to truthful information gave Bethany unimaginable power to manipulate both sets of my parents. When there is no truth and openness there are no checks and balances.
I Agree
I understand what you are going through. Dealing with B.C.S. Was the worst thing that has ever happened to me, nothing about my adoption was legal. I have been trying to do my own investigation. If you would like to talk. E-mail me at:bramlett_anna@yahoo.com